A customer emails asking for your product’s carbon footprint. Another, the same week, asks for an LCA. Are they asking for the same thing?
Not quite. A product carbon footprint (PCF) is one result from one impact category: climate change. A life cycle assessment covers that and more. The method underneath is the same, which is exactly why the two get mixed up.
What a product carbon footprint is
A PCF adds up the greenhouse gas emissions (and any removals) linked to one product across its life cycle, or a defined part of it, and expresses the total in kilograms of CO2 equivalent per unit. The main standards are:
- ISO 14067:2018, the international standard for the carbon footprint of products
- The GHG Protocol Product Standard, formally the Product Life Cycle Accounting and Reporting Standard
- PAS 2050, the older British specification
ISO 14067 is built on the LCA standards, ISO 14040 and ISO 14044. Put simply, a PCF is an LCA that looks at one impact category. It follows the same four steps and draws on the same kind of inventory data.
When the study stops at your factory gate, ISO 14067 treats it as a partial carbon footprint, because it covers only part of the life cycle. That’s what most B2B customers ask for. They’ll add the rest of the life cycle themselves.
What a full LCA adds
A full LCA under ISO 14040 and 14044 looks at several impact categories at once: climate change, plus others such as resource depletion, water use, acidification, human toxicity and ecotoxicity.
Why that matters comes down to trade-offs. A change that cuts carbon can push something else up. A new material might lower emissions but raise water use or toxicity. A carbon-only study can’t see that. A full LCA can.
Side by side
| Product carbon footprint | Full life cycle assessment | |
|---|---|---|
| Impact categories | Climate change only | Several, including climate change |
| Main standards | ISO 14067, GHG Protocol Product Standard, PAS 2050 | ISO 14040, ISO 14044 |
| Result | kg CO2e per unit of product | A result per impact category, per functional unit |
| Typical uses | Customer carbon requests, supplier data for a buyer’s Scope 3 | Design and material choices, trade-off analysis, BRSR Principle 2, wider sustainability claims |
| Data needed | A product inventory of materials, energy and emissions | Largely the same inventory, used for more impact categories |
A PCF isn’t your company footprint either
Another common mix-up. Your company footprint (Scope 1, 2 and 3) covers everything the organisation does over a year. A PCF covers one product. They share some data, especially energy, but they answer different questions. If you need the company-level number, our guide on how to calculate your company’s carbon footprint walks through it.
CBAM is different again. It asks for embedded emissions per tonne of covered goods under the EU’s own rules and boundaries. A PCF gives you a head start on the data, not a finished CBAM figure. More on that in CBAM default values.
Which one does your customer actually want?
Read the request closely.
- If it asks for kg CO2e per unit, a PCF, or data for their Scope 3 purchased goods, it’s a carbon footprint. Check whether they name a method, such as ISO 14067 or WBCSD’s PACT methodology.
- If it mentions ISO 14040/14044, several impact categories, or an Environmental Product Declaration, it’s a full LCA.
- If it’s vague, ask what they’ll use the number for and which boundary they need. Most of the time it’s cradle-to-gate.
Why we usually suggest the full LCA
Here’s the practical point. The expensive part of both is the same: collecting the inventory data (our LCA data checklist shows what that involves). Once it’s done, calculating extra impact categories adds little work.
So if there’s any chance you’ll need more than carbon in the next year or two, from another customer, a design decision or BRSR, doing the full LCA now saves you collecting the same data twice. The climate change result from the LCA gives you the carbon number your customer asked for. If they need it reported under a specific standard, raise that at the start, because each standard has its own reporting rules.
Questions we get asked
What is the difference between a product carbon footprint and an LCA? A product carbon footprint measures one impact, greenhouse gas emissions, per unit of product. A life cycle assessment covers several impact categories, including climate change, so it shows trade-offs a carbon-only study would miss.
Which standard is used for a product carbon footprint? ISO 14067:2018 is the main international standard. The GHG Protocol Product Standard and PAS 2050 are also used.
Is a product carbon footprint the same as Scope 3? No. A product carbon footprint covers one product’s life cycle. Scope 3 covers a company’s indirect value chain emissions over a year. A supplier’s product footprint often feeds into its customer’s Scope 3.
What is a cradle-to-gate carbon footprint? One that covers emissions from raw material extraction up to the point the product leaves your factory. ISO 14067 calls a footprint that covers only part of the life cycle a partial carbon footprint.
Can one study give me both a carbon footprint and an LCA? Yes. A full LCA includes climate change as one of its impact categories, so the carbon result comes out of the same study and the same data.
Bilancia Consulting is an Ahmedabad based sustainability and ESG advisory firm. We carry out full ISO 14040/14044 life cycle assessments for Indian manufacturers, modelled in SimaPro, and help companies with GHG accounting. If a customer has asked for carbon data on your product and you’re not sure what they need, a short call will sort it out.
Call +91-9510144494 or email general@bilanciaconsulting.co.in